Reviewer: Sharon Brunner
Bonnie Jo Campbell’s The Spirits offers a story about traumatic family secrets as a result of an abusive patriarchal tyrant and an absent mother. The story begins with Doug and Mary traveling to spend time with his family. His mother and her two younger children, Beth and Trevor, are waiting for them to arrive. The family waits for Sister, the oldest child, to arrive at the family home to celebrate Christmas. It’s Christmas Eve. She takes her time walking through the snow, hauling a large box of wine in her backpack, dreading the encounter after her poor behavior last Christmas. Sister has a drinking problem, and she struggles with remorse and deeply rooted shame issues. The story takes place in Paw Paw, Michigan, near Kalamazoo in the southwest part of the state. A town best known as a historic winemaking hub. Campbell lives in Kalamazoo, Michigan. Sister begins the healing process with the rest of her family on that fateful Christmas Eve night.
Some of the main themes of this story are shame and self-loathing. Sister starts her self-loathing after she goes on a hunting trip with her father. They hunt for partridge, which is usually driven out of hiding and shot. Instead of ducking when the partridge sprang from the ground, she stares at the bird and ends up being shot in the face and shoulder by her father. She blames herself for not getting out of the way. Birdshot ammo contains dozens of small lead, steel, or tungsten pellets inside a single shell, which are designed to spread out upon firing to hit fast-moving airborne small prey. Sister’s father used a knife to remove the pellets from Sister’s face and shoulder. To deaden the pain, her father forced her to drink whiskey, which added to her nausea. Her father tells her she must keep the incident a secret and say she fell out of a tree. The accident also deforms her ear. Because she thinks her father cares about her when he carefully removes the pellets, she tells him she loves him. He does not return the sentiment. Doug has been repeatedly beaten by his father throughout his childhood. The two younger children appear to escape the abuse.
A rare situation occurs when Sister agrees to spend the night at the family home on Christmas Eve, resulting in Doug’s birth. Her mother gave birth to Sister when she was about 14 years old. She ran into the arms of their father when escaping a terrible situation at her family home. Sister decides to fall in her father’s footsteps, especially after his death, and works her fingers to the bone at a nursery for plants and trees. She becomes a valuable employee and provides for her family’s living expenses. Sister drops out of school like her father did at the age of 16. Her family end up fearing her because of her temper and believe she has a stubborn streak. They do not view her as being in pain and in need of support and love.</p?
When I read the book and how sadistic Sister’s father is, I am reminded of the book and documentary called “A Child Called It” about the trauma Dave Pelzer suffers as the result of his mother’s abuse. It was one of the most severe and graphic cases of child abuse in California history. It starts when he is in first grade. His emotionally unstable, alcoholic mother stops viewing him as a son and starts calling him “the boy” and” it.” She starves, beats, forces him to drink chemicals, burns, and treats him as a slave while isolating him from his brothers. Sister’s father makes her feel it is her fault for shooting her with the birdshot. She is forced to drink whiskey to deaden the pain. The family witnesses their mother and brother Doug being beaten on a regular basis. Sister rescues the family by shooting her father and community members and her family called his murder death by lightning because of his cruel demeanor. I am aware of families who have encountered similar circumstances.
I recommend The Spirits for its poignant view of family trauma, because of its accurate depiction of self-loathing, and for its example of family healing. Sister felt alone with her pain and turned to overworking, alcoholism, anger and self-loathing. Her family let her do her thing out of fear of her but at the same used her to pay for their household bills. She took on the family’s pain while her mother and brother Doug got on with their lives by obtaining scholarships for continuing education while she did not even have a high school diploma. Sister has worked very hard at her place of employment and became unreplaceable. She ends up caring more for trees than for people. She finally comes clean about her pain from past trauma and her family comforts her and tells her she is free from blame. She regrets missing out on so much when she was estranged from her family. The author names the book “The Spirits” which may relate to Sister seeing and hearing her father’s ghost and Sister’s use of alcohol to deal with her pain. Alcoholic beverages are also referred to as spirits. Campbell captures the intricacies and complications of family trauma while exhibiting steps to recovery.
Title: The Spirits
Author: Bonnie Jo Campbell
