Honorable Edward N. Breitung, with son Edward and Granddaughter Juliet, by Michael S. Nyquist

Review by Mack Hassler

I had heard so much about Edward Breitung in the earlier books by Nyquist that I had written about that I wanted to review this volume immediately.  In fact, I am so grateful for the opportunity to write about books on the “founders” of our nation – George Washington, John Adams, Abigail Adams; fewer about the individuals who helped create the culture and the existence of our region. A little bit on Douglas Houghton, some on Henry Rowe Schoolcraft and on the first Governor Cass. Michael S. Nyquist has undertaken a huge project of research and storytelling, and I feel fortunate that Victor has asked me to review a good number of them.

This new book on Germans who immigrated to our region of the Upper Peninsula, actually when the German identity itself was threatened in Europe in the mid-nineteenth century (this review is very German, as it turns out), is a fascinating book, filled with German family and also filled with intrigue.  It is a candid book filled with chronologies and with important photographs) and mysterious at the same time.  One has to sort through modes of story and narration

Not surprisingly, many of the founders are related.  The ancient story is that Aeneas carried his father on his back out of the burning city of Troy and went on to found  the even greater city of Rome.  Clearly, history teaches us that is a great danger as well as a blessing to want to dominate and to control our neighbors , to build Empirescity of Carthage .  .  This book, as its title suggests, is about Breitungs, not an easy family to comprehend.   The surname itself in the original German language is difficult to pronounce with the “u” in the second syllable taking on long and complex vowel sounds – a proud German family–. Once they arrived here, the name itself usually went by “Breiting” (p ( 2).

My review. As most of my work with Nyquist, will focus on the “founding” of a UP culture intended to last far into the future, based on mining, investment, and family.  By no means is it a celebration of race, power, or nationality, and, clearly, not one language.  Our founders were British, French, native  American and, very much, pioneers moving West to defeat the forests and the harsh weather coming in from the cold winds blowing in across the continent. Some of the other influences had to do with “sexuality” [Aeneas had to leave his True Love Dido in the burning city of Carthage and travel sadly on to found the race of Rome].

More importantly, still, some of the Breiting family never gave up their “Germanness”— they supported the German side in the Great War.  And sexually, they stood by their women. Martin Luther did not leave the Roman Catholic Church just for theological reasons, there was a Nun whom he wanted to marry; and Luther “stood  by his woman.”  But first the Great War and German support of it by Breitings

At the top of page 193, Nyquist prints a very cocky (even sinister looking  photograph) of Max Breitung who was both a grandnephew and a cousin of both Edward Breitungs named in the title of Nyquist”s book  This cocky- looking guy with two of his German friends were involved in plots to seize two of Edward senior’s ships (he owned many ships connected with his several mining businesses. (The plot involved blowing up American munitions factories and merchant ships to hurt the American war efforts (p.194).

The story has been picked up by writers in the wider history. It appears as the lead review in my copy the copy in the mail.  The review is of a book by Anne Berman, entitled “The fabulous Michigan Gatsby” (I reviewed the Berman book here September 1, 2025).

“The Kaufmans and Breitungs now had all the banks in Marquette, except for Longyear’s National Bank.  Edward Breitung,Jr. also ran the Munising State Bank forty miles to the East, and would also add the Neguunee National Bank ten miles to the West.” (Nyquist 121).

“The Huron Mountain Clib just west of Big Bay, was established by John M Longyear in 1889 to provide hunting and fishing within a large private preserve. Membership was exclusive and was limited to 50….The Kaufmans were never members , perhaps excluded due to their Jewish and Native  blood…. Jumping ahead a bit, Louis Kaufman (the Gatsby in the Berman book) apparently found this  Offensive and started to build Granot Loma in 1919 completed in  1924. It was closer to Marquette…than the Huron Mountain Club (worth about $84 million at the time of completion) (Nyquist, 114)

I suspect any readers who delve into this very complex book (nearly as interfaced and complex in its presentation of characters as the book by Catherine Katz that I use as my second epigraph) will be even more interested in the sexual shenanigans pursued by the Breitungs than their efforts to undermine the war efforts, nor their financial wizardry ).  (We won the war.   Sexual shenanigans are always with us in our fallen genes)   The senior Edward had “a tryst with Bertha Zuleger”  (p.3) Note that Nyquist mentions this very early in his book.  He knows that it is more interesting than the efforts to undermine the Great War efforts, or even their banking)

We learn later that Edward was happily married and produced seven children with his wife.   Very late in the book we find a good photograph of “Grace Mary … Bertha’s daughter … born in 1884…  [who] had never been told the full truth as to who was her real father” and more details about her life (pp 302-303).   DNA tests had been done on her and on the seven legitimate children from Edward’s marriage.   But the tests were not conclusive.  The story sounds nearly as interesting as the stories we have of one of our favorite Founding Fathers of the United States— Thomas Jefferson and his “tryst” with one   of his slave women.   Maybe the genre has its own conventions.    Buy the book. I think Nyquist has woven together with his lists and chronologies a fascinating web of characterization for a founding family of our culture with nearly as many good photographs , though less dramatic, as my fun read by Katz.


Review of Honorable Edward N. Breitung, with son Edward and Granddaughter Juliet, by Michael S. Nyquist,

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.